Project overview
Choosing a material looks simple on a datasheet and turns expensive when it is wrong. The client had a rod structure, fixed at its base, whose rods take direct hits from stones, and four candidate polymers: polycarbonate, PA11, PA12 and PA12CF, the carbon-fibre-filled version of PA12.
A datasheet gives a material property; it does not say how far the part will bend when something hits it, because that depends on the geometry as much as the material. So we ran a static structural finite element analysis (FEA) in Ansys on the same geometry with each material, and swept the load from 8 N to 12 N to check whether the ranking held as the impacts got harder. The result was a clear winner and, just as usefully, a clear material to avoid.
Objectives
How we set up a fair comparison
Supports and loads
A fixed support at the bottom of the structure, as it is mounted, and a force applied directly to each rod to represent the stones striking it.
Mesh
Linear elements at 1 mm size, about 478,000 elements and 847,000 nodes, fine enough to capture bending along the slender rods.
Four materials
Polycarbonate, PA11, PA12 and PA12CF, each with its own stiffness and strength. Only the material changed between runs.
Load sweep
Each material run at 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 N per rod, reporting total deformation and normal (bending) stress.
Keeping the geometry, mesh, supports and loads identical makes the comparison fair: any difference in the results comes from the material and nothing else.
Results: stiffness separates the materials
The gap between the best and worst material was much wider than the datasheets suggest. In every case the maximum deflection was at the free ends of the rods, farthest from the fixed base:
| Material | Deflection at 8 N | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| PA11 | 2.58 mm | The stiffest at every load: recommended |
| PA12 | 4.13 mm | A reasonable middle option |
| PA12CF | 5.17 mm | Between PA12 and polycarbonate in this model |
| Polycarbonate | 9.39 mm | About 3.6 times PA11, reaching 14.09 mm at 12 N |

Polycarbonate is the material to avoid here. A rod that bends that far absorbs a hit by getting out of the way, and risks touching whatever sits behind it. PA11 keeps the rods stiffest, so the structure holds its shape and takes the shock rather than folding away from it.

The load sweep showed that the ranking never changes. Every material deflects in a straight line as the load rises and the ratios stay fixed, with polycarbonate at about 3.6 times PA11 at every load. That linearity means the deflection at any load in this range can be read off without another simulation, and confirms nothing yields or behaves oddly.
Why the stress is the same for every material
The maximum bending stress was about 5.22 MPa, and it was the same for all four materials. That is not an error, it is physics: in a statically determinate structure like this one, the internal stress is set by the load and the geometry, not by the material's stiffness. A different material bends a different amount, but the stress carrying the load stays the same.

Since all four materials see the same modest stress, none is anywhere near breaking. Strength is not the deciding factor here; stiffness is, and on stiffness the materials differ by nearly a factor of four.
The recommendation: PA11
Every candidate is strong enough, so the choice comes down to which keeps the rods stiffest when stones hit them, and PA11 wins at every load in the range by a wide margin. Polycarbonate, despite being the obvious first thought, turned out to be the worst of the four. The client got that answer from one model and a handful of runs, instead of building and testing four versions of the part. The same thinking applies to flexible plastic features, as in our guide to snap-fit design with FEA.
Frequently asked questions
Which polymer was best for the rod guard?
PA11. It kept the rods stiffest at every load from 8 N to 12 N, deflecting 2.58 mm at 8 N, against 4.13 mm for PA12, 5.17 mm for PA12CF and 9.39 mm for polycarbonate.
Why did polycarbonate perform so badly?
It is the least stiff of the four in this structure: at 8 N it deflected about 3.6 times further than PA11, and 14.09 mm at 12 N. A rod that bends that far absorbs a hit by moving out of the way and can touch whatever sits behind it.
Why was the bending stress the same for all four materials?
In a statically determinate structure, the internal stress depends only on the load and the geometry, not on the material's stiffness. All four materials carried the same peak bending stress of about 5.22 MPa; they only bent by different amounts.
How was the comparison kept fair?
The geometry, the 1 mm mesh (about 478,000 elements), the fixed support at the base and the loads were identical in every run; only the material changed, so any difference in the results comes from the material alone.



















